Lyle’s rewritten six verse text message is approximately synchronous toward songster text shortly after deletion of next verse of second. Lyle’s rewritten adaptation, but not, has the routine going to Kilkenny, as opposed to Killarney. Lyle together with blogged a different sort of track on tune, given in the functions quoted, and published earlier having music. Lyle’s tune is actually «The fresh new Bonnie Blue Disregard-Me-Perhaps not,» that has been provided when you look at the R. A great. Smith’s The brand new Irish Minstrel , n.d. [1825, the initial, supposedly pent up, edition]. The newest name of tune can there be considering because «The newest Housemaid of Derby.» While Lyle’s text message «Fairly Peg off Derby» was meaningless once the a traditional track, we could make certain «Fairly Peggy away from Derby» try sung when you look at the Scotland in the 1st one-fourth of the nineteenth century which have a text nearly the same as one to in the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text as opposed to an excellent chapbook or broadside content seems Roy Palmer’s present Everyman’s Book of Ballads. ]
Maybe a bit before «Pretty Peggy away from Derby, O» try rewritten as the «The brand new Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie» since the confirmed because of the a duplicate when you look at the Peter Buchan’s MSS on United kingdom Collection, which happen to be believed to big date regarding 1828.
The original line . 5, almost just like men and women significantly more than, are for the a good medley when you look at the Vol. We, p. cuatro, 1825. You’ll find musical towards tune «Very Peggy from Derby, O» to the p. 107 and you may 276 away from Vol. III, 1828, in addition to first line out of «Peggy off Darby» is during an excellent medley towards the p. 284.
Cahusac when you look at the 1788, and an individual layer tune that have musical is within a few American selections, «Peggy of Darby», and that begins «There’s good gay Head inside the Darby City»
T. Crofton Crocker on Prominent Musical from Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 regarding 1886 reprint), claims, «Brand new very Housemaid out-of Derby, O!» is known to be producing an enthusiastic Irishman, but become will bring no particulars whatever, not really bringing up where a copy of the text otherwise tune could be discovered. It would appear that Crocker requested his customers is familiar to the track and you may song. The data quoted a lot more than generally seems to us to become a bit conclusive to take «Pretty Peggy out of Derby» becoming an enthusiastic Irish tune and you may track. Without having which facts, but not, there have been counterclaims. Wm. Chappell inside Tunes of Olden Date , II, p. 771, detailed Crocker’s allege, but required your tune wasn’t Irish, not, the guy offered no head proof. Chappell’s report you to Bunting declined it is instead of basis. Bunting failed to discuss the track, which is most certainly not like stating he rejected they. away from Grove’s Dictionary , but cites zero evidence pro or scam, therefore we have no idea just what proof he previously seen, if any.
Lastly, two activities We haven’t yet , viewed. There was a copy of your own pay attention an excellent flute teacher authored by T. BUCEM listing no copy regarding the about United bedste Hong Kong-datingwebsteder kingdom Countries.
Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs that have Chappell within his post on Irish Folk-music for the the latest fifth ed
Unrelated: «Falls regarding Brandy» was a significantly older unrelated track out of similar label, also known as «Dribbles out of Brandy.» The latter name Thomson’s song to the tune in his Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Upset Gallant’, 1738. A few years later so it tune are copied towards the NLS MS 6299. New track you certainly will admission towards the amazing you to with the track whenever we don’t remember that the newest tune is earlier. «The latest Dandy, O,» Thomas Moore’s track to own their tune «Young Can get Moonlight» from inside the fifth level of Irish Tunes , letter.d. try an alternative listen six/8 date having similar term, evidently given by Moore in the chorus out-of a tune inside Robin Bonnet where the song checked instead name.